A while ago, I interviewed Gord Sellar about Something Tookish!, how he got into gaming, how he found his way to Carved from Brindlewood, and what drew him to write a cozy halfling mystery game. That conversation made me want to read the game more carefully. So I did. Here's where I landed.
Something Tookish! is a Carved from Brindlewood hack for halfling village cozy mysteries. You can find it at Gord's itch page. The mechanical DNA is clearly Brindlewood Bay: 2d6 moves, a Theorize move at the core, a long-arc mystery layered under individual sessions. If you've played Brindlewood Bay or any of its cousins, the bones are familiar. The changes Gord made are mostly in service of tone.
The game's central tension isn't murder and cosmic dread. It's something gentler: the pull between the comfortable conformity of village life and a restlessness that won't quite stay quiet. Each halfling carries two competing tracks, A Jolly Hat and A Sombre Hat, which replace Brindlewood Bay's Crown mechanics. It's a smart translation. The pressure the system creates is real without being grim.
A few specific design choices caught my attention.
The Musical Move is a helping mechanic borrowed from Josh McCrowell's Under Hill, By Water. A player sings a verse or recites a poem related to the action at hand, and the character they're helping gets a +2 on the roll. It's optional, and the player aids sheet provides rhyme words and opening lines for anyone who freezes up. What I appreciate is how deliberately the game lowers the barrier. It's asking players to do something potentially uncomfortable (improvise verse), and it provides scaffolding rather than demanding performance.
Gord also includes a worked example for every move. That's a small thing that does significant work, especially for GMs new to the CfB family who haven't yet built intuition for how moves interact with fiction. It's the kind of generosity that shows up in play.
The mystery structure has some interesting adjustments as well. Rather than location descriptions, the game uses Paint the Scene sections: clusters of questions for players to answer when their halflings arrive somewhere. This hands authorial work to the table and keeps the Keeper from front-loading the world. It pairs well with the game's general disposition toward collaborative fiction-building.
One thing I missed was Moments, the little encounter-style scenes from later editions of Brindlewood Bay. Something Tookish! is built on a pre-Kickstarter version of the rules, and Moments didn't exist yet.
The four mysteries in the Keeper Sheets are well-suited to the setting: a missing muffin tin at the village bake-off, disappearing dwarven contractors, stolen garden vegetables, halflings accused of a theft they didn't commit. They're cozy without feeling toothless. The Strange Clues that hint at darker undercurrents are well-judged, weird without being out of register.
Here's where I'd place Something Tookish! on the radar chart:
The game sits in narrow, well-realized fictional range, it commits hard to its halfling village with shared narrative authority, and a tone well toward Pure Play. GM Scaffolding is moderate: the mystery structure gives you a lot to work with. Player On-Ramp is low in the best sense: you can walk right in.
If your table likes Tolkien, likes cozy mysteries, and has been curious about Carved from Brindlewood, this is a solid entry point. My table hasn't gotten to it yet, but I'm looking forward to the bake-off mystery in particular.
The question I keep turning over: the Sombre Hat track ends in retirement, your character turning their back on the village for good. That's a meaningful arc with real weight. But in a game this cozy, how much do players actually want to push into that territory? My guess is the answer varies a lot by group. I'm curious whether anyone has run a full campaign arc through to that conclusion.
No comments:
Post a Comment